Photo array lineup vs in person lineup

Because the evidence was heavily degraded, the profile obtained was limited to four STR markers. Suggestive conduct may include anything that a person says or does that might influence the witness to identify a particular individual.

Law and Human Behavior, 26 4doi: The "distractors" are poorly chosen.

Eyewitness Identification

CR5—, CR5— ; W. Otherwise, the evidence if admissible in all other respects should be submitted to the jury. Law and Human Behavior, 12, Neither Perry nor the dissent, however, points to a single case in which we have required pretrial screening absent a police-arranged identification procedure.

BastaldoMass. See also Henderson, N. Later the clerk views a photospread and identifies the "customer. How far apart were the witness and the person. Are they superior to simultaneous lineups.

We reach a similar conclusion here: Appellant testified that he believed J. One protects against bias; one does not.

When it comes to strangers, however, identifications are frequently in error.

Police lineup

He contends, however, that it was mere happenstance that each of the Stovall cases involved improper police action. We have all seen TV shows depicting a witness trying to identify a bad guy from an array of people in a lineup.

See post, at 6, 9, 14— They may be asked to speak words uttered by the perpetrator or to perform other actions of the perpetrator. Seventy-two tests of the sequential lineup superiority effect: But in some areas using photos instead is seen as a huge advantage.

I observed this person engaged in this kind of activity," said Turner. To show how reliable or unreliable photo line-ups are, WREG asked the University of Memphis Criminal Justice Club to help. State), a photo array was impermissible when the defendant’s photo was the only “mug shot” showing the location of a custodial facility and an identification number.

• In a Pennsylvania. Suspect Identification 1. Lineup and Photo Array Suspect Identification Jake J. Koppenhaver CJ Professor Brown February 9, Suspect Identification 2 Lineup and Photo Array Suspect Identification Nothing short of a solid, accepted confession can bolster the spirits of investigators and solidify their position in a case quite like witness 5/5(8).

The Commonwealth has the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is the person who committed [or participated in] the alleged crime[s].

written policies and training on photo array and live lineup administration. Police should use blind procedures to avoid the unintentional or intentional exchange of information that. Suspect Identification 1.

Showups, Lineups, and Photo Arrays

Lineup and Photo Array Suspect Identification Jake J. Koppenhaver CJ Professor Brown February 9, Suspect Identification 2 Lineup and Photo Array Suspect Identification Nothing short of a solid, accepted confession can bolster the spirits of investigators and solidify their position in a case quite like witness identification.5/5(8).

On December 19,police officers arranged a four-person lineup, includingBowden was shown a five-person photo array including Petitioner and four others who had similar physical characteristics, including skin complexion. Bowden selected Petitioner as the shooter.

Photo array lineup vs in person lineup
Rated 0/5 based on 33 review
Live Lineups, Photo Lineups, and Showups